Spanking children doesn't help them learn self-control or social skills, and studies consistently show that spanking increases a child's risk of developing behavior problems. But how can we be sure that spanking is harmful, and what can parents do instead when their children misbehave? Parents don't automatically spank their children. It depends on their perceptions of what's normal or expected Chiocca And among some groups — like hunter-gatherers — corporal punishment was rare, or altogether absent Ember and Ember
We aren't comfortable until we know where the Spnaking of correct and incorrect behavior are located. American Academy of Pediatrics Spanking older children stance against spanking Nov. Exercise 3. Although the study was small in scope, it can help provide a biological basis for other observations about corporal punishment, Dr. Robert Larzelere and his colleagues have wondered about Finger in clit point. Exercise 1.
Womens lingerie large cup bras bullit. The effects of spanking children
You can pick them up Spanking older children place them over your lap. Anonymous November 12, at AM. Why would I want to use an ineffective form of punishment? The new analysis also did Spanking older children completely overcome the lumping problem: It considered slapping and hitting children anywhere on Teen girls gettting fucked body as synonymous with spanking but these actions might have distinct effects. How hard? I told her that Sasha was going to get a Spanking older children for disobeying me and she was avoiding me. Research shows that spanking, just like other forms of violence, harms the parent-child bond. Only ignore behavior that poses no harm to your child or other people. My mom spanked me when I was younger, and I'm glad she did. Remember you are the parent, not the Spankimg. Spanking and child development during the first 5 years of life.
The short answer is no.
- To spank or not to spank?
- Print article.
- Spanking children doesn't help them learn self-control or social skills, and studies consistently show that spanking increases a child's risk of developing behavior problems.
Barbara: The toddler and preschool years are a time to lay the groundwork for behavior and for moral choices in your…. Barbara: The toddler and preschool years are a time to lay the groundwork for behavior and for moral choices in your children. Dennis: At this time, you need to be a good student of your child and evaluate other forms of discipline that will work. For example, when our kids were at home we had a chore box—a highly productive form of discipline—for the kid who tried to get away with doing as little as possible.
We would have the child open the box, close her eyes, reach in, and draw one out. When our kids started griping and complaining frequently we found a jar and put some coins in it. Each time a child complained a coin was taken out of the jar. Thus, the jar is both a reward and a penalty. This process never ends with children, but you can drive these points home with punishments for negative behavior and rewards for positive behavior.
As children transition from grade school into junior high and high school, spanking becomes obsolete and you shift to removing opportunities and privileges from the offending child. Avoid undermining your own discipline. One of our neighbors grounded his son from driving his truck for two weeks because the boy was five hours late for dinner. But while the kid was grounded, his dad added a roll bar, a new stereo, and new wheels to his truck.
God, Spouse, Kids. Find global partners. Help for stepfamilies. Ministry Advisor. Make a donation. If you have questions about products, donations, registrations, etc. All Rights Reserved. Discipline and Spanking.
FamilyLife Podcast Network. Weekend to Remember. Yemen Zambia Zimbabwe. I Do, Every Day - a daily devotional for couples offering practical and relevant marriage and parenting advice. Who is FamilyLife? Be an Insider Donate Connect. Questions If you have questions about products, donations, registrations, etc.
Friedson The one featuring different world cultures? They have a great influence on kids' behavior. These aren't feelings that inspire kids to improve their behavior. You may think that is "sick and perverted". If your parents believe in spanking, or you can convince them to spank you, they might not care about your physical reaction to the punishment.
Spanking older children. Pagination
Adults don't deserve it just because they are adults - you have to earn it too. Children are treated with gentleness and kind parenting - and it shows in their behaviour. I am not saying EVERY child here is an angel - because human beings are all different and there will always be those who turn to crime and violence.
Strangely it may seem - even criminals are not hit no matter what the crime - so what on earth could a child possibly do that earns them something so harsh?? Put themselves in danger? It's really not that hard.
If an older child runs in the road etc - then tell them you will walk with them to their friends, school etc I spank my kids over the knee and bare bottom its a good way to dicipline my kids. I don't understand why some people call spanking abuse when there are real abusers out there, people who burn, or beat up their kids black and blue, or have sex with them. Why bother the courts with spanking? Its ridiculous. Some believe may not want to do it or believe in it but it can be an effective and discipline of a loving parent.
Just as one touch of the backside is 'too much'. It might not be rape, but it's still abuse!! For an adult OR a child. Especially a child. We don't need to bother the courts normally.. You can be as loving as you think, but if you hit that isn't loving at all.
Ask any victim of domestic violence. When my parents hit me, they lost my love, respect and trust and never regained it. If you really cannot parent without hitting a child, then you should get to some good gentle parenting classes. My sexual damage from childhood spanking. Since this is on the internet and it's anonymous, I can be honest.
I have never hard such a hard erection as I have right now. I think I just discovered I have a spanking fetish. I masturbated to this 4 times I'm 13 years old. I wish my parents would spank me, how can I get them to spank me, without seeing my erections during the spanking? They would stop if they knew I liked it. Hi, not sure what advice I can give you.
I personally see nothing wrong with spanking a boy your age, although if you look at my old blog you will see I used to have big reservations. I think masturbation is a sin, but I know people tend to indulge in it. I don't want to encourage that, but I see nothing wrong with punishing you. If your parents believe in spanking, or you can convince them to spank you, they might not care about your physical reaction to the punishment. He is masturbating, reading this post about hitting and hurting children.
He is telling you he has a fetish. And he is telling you he wants to get his parents to spank him. As for directing him to a site called 'Parenting and Spanking - Positive and Loving Discipline without Abuse' you are also sending this child information about a group of people who still believe that hitting children is right and the Bible and Christ don't matter. As I explained before..
HE never told us to hit our children. He died for us on the cross and he died for ALL of us not just children. HE is the only one who can forgive any sins.. I certainly hope you aren't using their real names, too?! Putting your children in danger of becoming targets for pedophiles, using your dear children as fodder for titillation, and publicly humiliating them are much worse even than spanking them.
Do you not realize there are people all over the world reading this and imagining your girls' butts, and here are photos of their faces to go along with those thoughts? You, Betty, are either extremely naive or extremely sick.
You should know that female and male bottoms are deemed private parts and kept covered for a reason -- because they are part of our sexuality. Even if you aren't thinking of sex when you spank them, others are.
Please protect your kids, and if that is how you insist on disciplining them, the least you can do is keep it private! As you said, even when she isn't thinking of sex when she spanks, others are So many grow up to have spanking fetishes because of this unbiblical and cruel treatment.
Who would ever know? Over-the-knee, bare bottom spanking is a purely natural form of educative correction. Instead of being soundly spanked for my childhood naughtiness stealing, lying, being rude and playing with matches , I was punished by the withdrawal of my mother's and my oldest sister's affection.
My mother admitted to me later in life that she would, in fact, spank my bottom if she had it to do over again. Very good! How old are your kids now? And what all do you spank with and what other postions? And would u ever spank them and record it? Growing up in the sixties was a lot different than now.
My siblings and my self were spanked bare bottom usually legs spread over the edge of a bed, depending upon the offending act. The humiliation as well as the pain seems to be a positive deterrent to repeat the offenses again. We were all disciplined until we were 16 in that manner.
I am retired military now and own a successful home repair business. All of my siblings have successful career and family as well. Spare the rod and spoil the child. Wednesday, December 16, Spanking Specifics. This is a response to an e-mail I received from someone who read my article on discipline. They wrote "Betty, I found your article on discipline very interesting. I too believe in spanking. I am a new parent, with a 1 year old child.
I was wondering about your experiences using spanking, as I will use it myself in the future. Do you mind sharing? I would be happy if you were willing to share specific times when you have used spanking. Thank you for writing. That person included a list of questions about spanking. My children, like all children, hate getting spanked, so when I tell them they are to receive one, they are never happy.
On average, I usually tell them they are getting a spanking, they cry and whine about how they don't want one, then they usually follow me to the spot and comply. Parents have to learn to deal with this, as it can be emotionally difficult to spank your child when you know they do not like it at all.
But there are times when they resist. Recently my daughter Sasha disobeyed me and I told her she was going to get a spanking. She immediately screamed at me "NO! I followed her as she ran out the door. This is a scenario I fear, but really it was just my daughter being hysterical rather than my daughter actually running away.
I walked out and stood by the door. She stopped running and turned to me. I calmly asked "Are you going to come inside, Sasha? I am not going to go chasing after you. Neither did I. Finally, a neighbor broke up the "stand off" as she walked by, asking what was wrong. I told her that Sasha was going to get a spanking for disobeying me and she was avoiding me. My neighbor, who happened to be pro-spanking as well, told Sasha "Its best if you just go inside and get it over with.
Somehow she got through to Sasha and Sasha walked over to me. I brought her inside, to her to the couch, and quickly bent her over my knee. I gave my little lecture once she was in position over my lap because I was worried she would try running off again. She was crying the whole time, but actually was much calmer.
I gave her the spanking, then told her not to run off like that again or she would get a much worse spanking. On the other spectrum, I've had times when my kids completely comply.
I remember one time Paige earned a spanking and I told her so, and she walked right over to me. I was already sitting down, and instead of waiting for my lecture she laid across my lap waiting for the spanking. I was a bit shocked, but gave a quick lecture anyway.
Usually they are very wiggly during the spanking, which is the reason why I think that using that over the lap position is the safest way to spank.
She cries, even screams, kicks her legs, tries to move around, tries to cover her bottom with her hand. These are things you need to expect if you choose to use spanking. Its hard, sometimes discouraging, but you have to tell yourself you are doing it for their good and that you are shaping their behavior which you are.
I don't do it mainly because it is not necessary. I am not opposed to it though. Once the spankings stop hurting as much, I may start pulling the pants down, although you have to be careful to respect their privacy.
Now, I have spanked over their panties before, mainly when they wear skirts. With a skirt, it is difficult sometimes to see their bottom, especially with the fluffier skirts. So what I do is once they are over my knee I flip their skirt up and turn it against their shirt, then give the spanking as normal over their panties. In this case, yes. A couple months ago I had a babysitter over to take care of my kids while I was out for the evening.
She said that my girls weren't behaving, for whatever reason. I called my girls over and asked them why they were not behaving. They all were very guilty, none of them answering. The babysitter said that Sasha had gotten them all riled up and wild. So I said to the babysitter with my kids present "You know what I'm going to do? I'm going to give each of them a spanking then have them apologize to you. I sat down on the couch and called them over. I asked my kids "Okay, who's first?
I asked the babysitter if she would be offended if I spanked my kids in front of her, because I wanted them to understand that they were getting spanked for disrespecting her, and having her present would send a stronger message. She said she didn't mind. So I had Sasha bend over my knee and gave her 10 hard spanks. I could tell the babysitter was a little uncomfortable seeing it, and Sasha was very uncomfortable getting it, but it seemed like the appropriate thing to do.
I did the same with Paige and Michaela. After all three had been spanked I had them stand in front of the babysitter and apologize to her. That situation came to mind when you asked that question. But yes, there are lots of times when I have to spank two or all three of my kids.
I simply go about it the same, only the other one is waiting for her turn. I've done the quick one swat spank as they are standing, simply to stop them from their behavior.
For example, when they are running around or being sassy in public and want them to shape up quickly without making a big deal out of it. But I don't recommend doing that, I am just saying that I have done that.
I remember sitting at a park bench spanking one of my daughters. I remember going into another room at a guests house and giving a spanking. They found that spanking was associated with 13 out of a total of 17 negative outcomes they assessed, including increased aggression and behavioral and mental health problems as well as reduced cognitive ability and self-esteem.
The meta-analysis was not simply an attempt to synthesize studies—Gershoff and Grogan-Kaylor also wanted to address two concerns often raised about the body of research linking spanking to childhood problems. They may have been spanked because they were acting out back then, too. To address these issues, Gershoff and Grogan-Kaylor did several things.
First, they limited their meta-analysis to studies that evaluated the effects of spanking, slapping and hitting children without the use of objects, and found that spanking is still associated with negative outcomes.
Gershoff and Grogan-Kaylor found that spanking is associated with negative outcomes in both types of studies, which strengthens the argument that spanking poses risks. Yet some researchers remain skeptical. The new analysis also did not completely overcome the lumping problem: It considered slapping and hitting children anywhere on the body as synonymous with spanking but these actions might have distinct effects. Some research also suggests that the effects of spanking differ depending on the reasons parents spank, how frequently they do so and how old children are at the time—so the conclusion from the meta-analysis that spanking itself is dangerous may be overly simplistic.
Finally, the associations reported in the meta-analysis between spanking and negative outcomes did not control for the potential mediating effects of other variables, which raises the chicken-or-egg question: Are kids spanked because they act out or do they act out because they are spanked—or both?
To rule out the possibility that spanking is only associated with bad outcomes because poorly behaved kids are the ones getting spanked, researchers can use statistical methods to control for the influence of temperament and preexisting behavioral characteristics—but these methods are difficult to employ in meta-analyses, and the new analysis did not attempt such a feat.
As a further demonstration of the importance of careful statistical controls, Robert Larzelere, a psychologist at Oklahoma State University, and his colleagues reported in a study that grounding and psychotherapy are linked just as strongly to bad behavior as spanking is but that all the associations disappear with the use of careful statistical controls.
Still, a number of individual studies have found associations between spanking and negative outcomes, even after controlling for preexisting child behavior. So Gershoff says that in spite of the lingering controversy, the safest approach parents can take is not to spank their kids.
When is a Child too Old to Spank?
Spanking looks to be instantly effective. If a child is misbehaving—if he keeps swearing, or playing with matches—and then you spank that child, the behavior stops immediately. The effect is so apparently obvious that it can drive a sort of delusion. One of the few memories that many people retain from early childhood is times they were spanked. Some 81 percent of Americans believe spanking is appropriate, even though decades of research have shown it to be both ineffective and harmful.
For years, the American Academy of Pediatrics has been warning against spanking, and many countries have laws against it. In the extremely depressing journal Child Abuse and Neglect , researcher Julie Ma and colleagues found that spanking was associated with later aggressive behavior. Ma has previously linked spanking to later antisocial behavior, anxiety, and depression.
Then last week The Journal of Pediatrics reported that researchers at the University of Texas found a correlation between corporal punishment as a child and dating violence as an adult. That one struck a chord in light of the national conversation about sexual harassment. Of course, no single act or momentary experience turns a person from a blank slate into a violent or coercive adult. To suggest that childhood experiences explain sexual violence ignores the structural power dynamics that condone and perpetuate it.
The words I choose to use here are loaded, I know. Many researchers tend to see corporal punishment and physical abuse as part of a continuum.
Administered too severely or too frequently, corporal punishment is abuse. The notion of a continuum is corroborated by the stated intent of abusers. He was influenced by one of the pivotal works in spank-theory discourse, a meta-analysis by Elizabeth Thompson Gershoff who is now also at the University of Texas, a geographically unlikely hotbed of resistance to corporal punishment. Our job is just to provide them the evidence of what works, and what happens long-term.
This abdication of the moral high ground is principled. He is fundamentally opposed to telling people what not to do. The other evidence-based approach he recommends is taking something positive away. For younger children, that can mean taking away a toy temporarily.
For older children and teenagers, this can mean taking away a cell phone. All of this is in service of teaching children to be respectful without disrupting the vital positive elements of the caretaker-child relationship. At a larger scale, Temple believes one promising approach is school-based teaching of relationship skills.
He is involved with a program call the Fourth R meaning relationships , which is dedicated to baking healthy adolescent relationships into the curriculum.
The ultimate target is violence of multiple sorts, including bullying, dating violence, peer violence, and group violence. But the focus is positive, not punitive, on how to build healthy relationships. Temple believes this work is relevant to the national conversation on sexual assault and harassment. The discourse is doing an extraordinary job punishing—and of telling people how not to behave.
Publicly accused perpetrators of sexual violence have been removed from their positions in droves, with the notable exceptions of Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore and President Donald Trump. At the same time, though, if there is evidence that punishment-based approaches are ineffective in children—and the behavior of these men is in many ways juvenile, egocentric, inhumane—then this punitive approach is at best incomplete.
It carries with it the risk of a false sense of progress. When the public perceives that we have cleansed the halls of Congress and corporations of the several bad eggs who commit sexual harassment violent or otherwise , how much of the structural problem is really solved?
In the interim before the total eradication of men, what keeps these positions from being filled again by bad eggs? The punitive phase will, it seems, need to go hand in hand with positive reinforcement. This seems absurd in an ostensibly civilized era: No one deserves a reward for being a basically reasonable respectful human.
Or maybe they do. There is no dispute that early exposures are critical to later social habits. Relationships with adults at a very young age shape how we learn to relate. The degree to which violence and perceived respect enter into that relationship are important.
That means teaching healthy relationships to everyone, but especially boys. I think that might be where the key is. We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters theatlantic. Facebook Twitter Email.